Reviewer's Note: Of all the reviews I have written over the years, I approach this one with the greatest hesitancy for fear of coming across as too picky and too negative, but here goes.
By way of introduction, as some of you know I am a veteran of over 26 cruises on lines ranging in quality from Crystal and QE2 (Grill Class), to the late, lamented Premier and Regency, and it is no secret that my favorite line is HAL. I have sailed NCL 3 times in the past, beginning with a woefully inadequate cruise on the then Seaward, now Norwegian Sea, followed by a spectacular sailing on the Dynasty, which ranks as one of my favorite ships ever, and then a delightful time on the brand new Norwegian Sky.
Bottom Line: I was looking forward to trying this new ship and freestyle cruising but sadly came away terribly disappointed. For those who don't want to read to the end, in brief, the Star is, in places, a spectacular ship, with some major design flaws, delivering a thoroughly underwhelming cruise, to some of the most beautiful places on earth.
As I said, the ship is, in places, truly spectacular. She is also the largest and most densely populated ship I have ever sailed on, which was part of my problem. I simply don't like ships this large, or crowds this big. From as early as embarkation I felt that the Star simply did not absorb crowds well. I read reviews of other equally large, or larger, ships which rejoice that you never get the sense of crowding. Not so here. No matter where you were, there was always a mass of people and lines for everything.
Her interior decor is wonderful: bright and exciting without being overwhelming or overdone. Every room was tasteful and elegant, I never wondered "why did they do that?" Obvious Asian touches (thank you Star Cruises) are everywhere and public rooms are well laid out, airy and kept immaculately clean. Soft furnishings are well designed and supremely comfortable, except in the Starlight Theater, the main showroom, where the theater style seating is simply too tight and too close together.
The Versailles Restaurant is truly one of the most magnificent dining rooms at sea, with its classical "grande decente" staircase reminiscent of the great French Line. If only the food came anywhere close to the surroundings, but more on that later.
Our cabin, #10516 was a standard balcony cabin forward on deck 10. It too was beautifully decorated with lots of cherry wood accents, although not as large as you would expect on a new ship. It was larger than the cabins on the Sky, but not in the same league as comparable accommodations on other ships.
Access to the balcony, via a sliding door, required that the beds be place across the room, instead of lengthwise to it. This resulted in a severe loss of floor space, and made for awkward movement when two people were trying to get by each other. The standard outside cabins without balcony are actually arranged much better, have considerably more movement space, and just "feel" roomier.
Positive cabin features: Everything you have read about the superbly designed cabin bathrooms is entirely true. Toilet, sink and very roomy shower are each in their own sliding door compartment. The result is no shower curtain to become intimately acquainted with. A million "thank you's" to whichever designer finally got it right and put a real hair dryer at the dressing table in the room instead of those anemic wall mounted things in a steamy bathroom.
I'm not sure if this is a Star Cruise innovation or not, but the service crew on deck, and in cabins and dining rooms, is overwhelmingly Eastern European women, principally Romanian and Ukrainian and Asian men. There are very few of the traditional Caribbean and South American staff who NCL once used almost exclusively.
With some notable excellent exceptions, most performed their jobs adequately, at best. While they all understood the "letter" of their job, few really understood the "spirit" of it. Your food order was taken and delivered, and if you wanted a drink, you got a drink, but rarely did it come with a smile or any indication that the server was doing anything more than performing a job.
Speaking of drinks, I have never been on a ship that hawked more variations of the "souvenir glass" then this one did. Morning to night, day in and day out, on ship and on shore, you always had the opportunity to sign for something colorful in a different shaped container, be it an official NCL tankard, tumbler, champagne flute, sports cup, daquiri glass, Margarita glass, yard of beer glass, etc. NCL must have a contract with every container company on earth.
There is no more personal part of any cruise than the quality of the food. This is one area where 5 people can have 5 different opinions and everyone is right. That being said, I found the food on the ship to be wildly, and maddeningly, uneven.
Free Dining Rooms (Poor): To my taste, the "free" dining rooms (Versailles, Aqua and Market Café Buffet) were poor, both in menu selections and quality of ingredients. Appetizers, soups and salads were the best bets, entrees were at best, fair, and better not to mention desserts.
Specialty Restaurants (Good to Excellent): The "pay" dining rooms ranged from very good (Endless Summer, no charge but reservations required), to excellent (Soho, $12.p.p. and Ginza, $10 p.p.) to awesome (Le Bistro, $12.50 p.p.). It seemed that the more you paid, the better the food.
Reservation Problems: The brochure seems to tell you that you have the option of making reservations or just showing up at all dining venues. Wrong. When the ship is full, the specialty places are booked solid one day in advance, unless you are willing to eat at 5:00 or after 9:00. Also, it is very difficult to dine with parties of 6 or more, each restaurant having only two or three tables which can accommodate that many.
Freedom Paradox: This is one of my biggest problems with this freestyle concept. In theory you are supposed to have greater freedom, in practice, it requires you to decide on Monday morning where and when you want to eat on Tuesday night! Should you decide not to decide, you are consigned to the regular dining rooms with (IMO) seriously inferior food. Where is the freedom here?
Entertainment Conflicts: When the ship first entered service, there was a major problem of everyone showing up to eat at the same time with resulting massive delays. To solve this, they increased the evening entertainment choices and spread them out at unusual times to stagger the crowds in the dining rooms. Great in theory, lousy in practice. Rather than giving you more choice, freestyle has actually given you fewer. You can have dinner OR see the show, not both, because by this time, you cannot change your dinner reservation; truly maddening.
I mentioned earlier about design flaws with the ship. Nowhere is this more obvious than on the pool deck. The main pool is far too small for the number of passengers, and open space is further reduced by the presence of a massive water slide, a natural magnet for small children even though they have their own at the aft end of the ship.
Shaded poolside seating is very limited, and really used more as a dining area for the outdoor buffet and the daily barbecue. The terraced sun decks are completely exposed and considering that this itinerary takes you to within 210 miles of the equator, this is really silly and dangerous unless you have sunscreen spf 300 with you.
First among the onboard positives is the Polynesian program. One of the major complaints upon entering service was the almost total lack of cultural activities for this itinerary. This has been completely changed. There is a "Hawaiian Ambassador" onboard, a gracious, beautiful woman passionately devoted to her heritage, and before you leave, you will be too.
Her arts and crafts program each day draws literally hundreds of people. She is in charge of a troupe of Polynesian dancers onboard who perform two shows that are simply superb. They also run a program of Hula lessons for those interested. Even if you don't take the lessons, do not miss the "graduation ceremony" for those who did. Bring your camera, a very open mind, and sit close.
The greatest positive however, is the itinerary. Because of the required jaunt to Fanning Island, much has been debated about the lack of time in Hawaii itself. It is true that the American Hawaii and United States Lines itineraries were far superior and gave you much more time on the islands, but since they are no longer an option, and since many don't have the time or money for the longer HAL, RCCL or Celebrity cruises from the West Coast, this is really the best you can do. After all, any time in Hawaii is better than no time at all.
NCL has always excelled in its shore/sports programs and here they really outdo themselves. Because of the limited time in port, their shore excursions are superb and comprehensive. I found them to be very fairly priced and expertly run. They really make the most of your limited time.
It is true that you have time to sightsee OR shop but not both. You will definitely not feel that you have been immersed in Hawaii, but rather you get a little taste of what to return to later. NCL's tweaking of the itinerary a while back put them in a catch-22 situation. By moving to Hilo and Kahului instead of Kona and Lahina they gained a dock with no tendering headaches, but those really are commercial ports located a great distance away from anything interesting.
Their pre-cruise package in Honolulu was wonderful, the Radisson Prince Kuhio Hotel was perfectly located and convenient to everything. Transfers and baggage handling was excellent. I imagine the post-cruise option would be just as good.
Beware however of the "orientation breakfast" they will advertise. Having been warned by others we ignored this, but it is no more than a pre-dawn wake up to be taken to a convention center for cold coffee and stale rolls, where tour companies will try to sell you various Oahu tours. This is not an NCL sponsored event, but run by the shoreside host company.
Final Thoughts: Thanks for staying with me for all this. Again, I'm sorry I don't have better things to say about freestyle cruising; I guess I'm a traditionalist at heart. Hawaii, and Fanning Island is beautiful and I'm thrilled I had the opportunity to go back to some of my favorite places. I will certainly return again, and probably on a ship, but sadly, not on NCL again until they make some major changes.
